David Israelson
Special to The Lake Report
I’m not going to comment on the choice of Frank Campion for chair of Niagara Region because I don’t know him. But isn’t that the point? I thought we lived in a democracy.
And in a democracy, how on earth did we get to the point where Niagara Region, population 539,180, is ruled by someone most of us don’t know and none of us chose?
The answer, of course is simple: this is Doug Ford’s doing. He has been dismantling local decision making ever since becoming Ontario premier in 2018. And disturbingly, Ford’s latest moves to concentrate power and take it out of our hands suggest that things are about to get worse.
In May, Ford’s government passed Bill 100, which it cynically called the Better Regional Governance Act. The new law slashed Niagara’s regional council from 19 elected members down to the 12 local mayors, which will include Niagara-on-the-Lake’s incoming lord mayor, Vaughn Goettler, plus a regional chair appointed by Ford.
Other than electing our own mayor, voters get no choice as to who sits on the regional council.
Ford also gave the new unelected chair “strong chair powers.” The new chair can direct the budget, hire and fire senior staff and more significantly, can veto bylaws that the 12-member council passes if he thinks they contradict what Ford’s government wants to do to develop Niagara Region.
To be fair, there is room to reform Niagara’s regional council, which over the years gained a reputation for gobbling up taxpayers’ money with too little accountability and too few accomplishments.
But Ford’s moves bring in a form of dictatorship, where the province calls the shots and Niagara residents have virtually no power to oppose the premier’s plans if the unelected chair decides to veto something.
This is significant and dangerous for two reasons. One, Ford has extensive plans to develop Niagara Region into a Las Vegas-like tourist magnet anchored by casinos. This could be acceptable if local residents had a say and our elected regional representatives could vote on these great big plans.
Don’t count on that. Ford has already said that, while he’s willing to meet with Niagara-area elected officials, “you can’t just sit back,” and the “status quo [for Niagara] is unacceptable.”
We don’t have a say anymore. To make matters worse, the second reason this is bad is that Ford is now ramming through another piece of legislation that could take away our right to even know what his plans for Niagara are before it’s too late.
Bill 140, introduced a day after the municipal elections, will alter environmental protection in Ontario to make it pretty much unrecognizable, and probably useless.
The Ford government calls the proposed law the Building Ontario Faster Act. It’s likely to make it easier to pave farmland, allow sprawl and silence anyone — including regional and town governments — who question potentially harmful development.
It would change a key rule that right now requires the Ontario government to post any regulations it proposes on the 32-year-old provincial Environmental Bill of Rights if its proposals might impact health, the environment or public safety. That way at least we’re warned.
Bill 140 would end this protection. The government would still have to post its nasty changes, but there’s no timeline and no central place to do so — it could do this they day a change takes effect, before we even know it’s happening.
Ontarians have only until Nov. 26 to comment on Bill 140 (see ero.ontario.ca/notice/026-1109). It would be nice if our regional government could do something too, but under the new system, Doug Ford calls the shots. So much for democracy.
David Israelson is a writer and non-practising lawyer who lives in Niagara-on-the-Lake.







