The Turner Report: In Frank we trust? Not so far

A sign of the times: Visitors streaming into Old Town will be told "Mississauga Road" is closed when they’re actually on Mississagua Street. So much for being unique. GARTH TURNER

Before they quit work last Friday, in twilight, the guys dumped detour signs flat on the shoulder of the road.

It’s happening. The main drag into Old Town is being torn up, widened, gentrified and expanded with fancy bike lanes, replica lights and a new walkway. Seventeen trees will make the ultimate sacrifice. Canopy and character will be lost. To progress.

The sign says it all: the closure is of “Mississauga Road,” it reads (that soulless six-lane artery to the east), and not our quirky “Mississagua Street” (note the spelling).

Yes, welcome to Mississauga, NOTL version. This bit of carelessness fits the legacy of the political leadership we all just tossed — when building and developing beats out preserving.

Will the sign be corrected? Dunno. But the challenge this bucolic little enclave faces is even larger now after the latest provincial action. And the face of that challenge is Frank.

Premier Doug Ford, whose Destination Niagara Strategy focuses on hotels, casinos, a sexed-up airport and double the number of tourists, has just named Frank Campion as regional chair. Actually, he’s more like a monarch.

His “strong” powers will let him set a budget, control staff or overturn a bylaw the yokels on regional council might pass that conflicts with provincial goals. He’s unelected and accountable to Queen’s Park — in other words, not voters.

Doug’s even giving Frank a “mandate letter.” That says it all.

Moreover, no longer is there an elected regional rep raising our voice at the region. Now, 12 mayors sit on the board. Our guy, Vaughn Goettler, is but one.

And “weighted voting” means we get zoomed 10 times out of 10 by the Falls or the Kitty. More population equals more clout. Frank, meanwhile, can pretty much orchestrate everything. So, he matters — more than those we just elected.

“I am simply concerned by what I see happening in the region,” says Goettler. “Our brand as a top tourist destination here in NOTL is not the brand of Niagara Falls. In fact, if we look at what brings people here, it is that we are not Niagara Falls, or Mississauga, or Toronto for that matter.”

Our feisty lord mayor has his job cut out for him. Ford wants to amalgamate us into the Niagara regional soup. And Campion has campaigned in the past not only for the premier, but also eliminating our local government.

Who is this guy?

He’s 69. The former mayor (for 12 years) of Welland. Born there. Owns a marketing company. Teaches. Ran to be a Progressive Conservative party member of the provincial legislature (and lost big to the NDP). Married to Liz for four decades. He’s tight with the Ontario Home Builders outfit, aligned with Ontario’s “build more faster” mandate.

Campion’s a bigtime Tory supporter. He used his mayor’s office to promote Ford during the 2025 election campaign — an unusual move that raised eyebrows and may have broken ethics rules. Mayors represent everybody. Not parties.

Yet Campion released a statement saying, “Having Doug Ford’s strong, stable leadership when it comes to negotiating with Donald Trump is critical to ensuring Ontario’s continued economic success.”

So how do our local poohbahs feel about Frank? Will they stand up to the premier’s surrogate?

Maybe. A few have fight in their eyes.

“I fundamentally disagree with the appointment of a regional chair,” says Weston Miller. “The position should be elected and directly accountable to Niagara residents. In my view, greater authority should come with greater democratic accountability, not less. I also disagree with Mr. Campion’s previously expressed support for municipal amalgamation.”

Steve McGuinness, meanwhile, is out for bear.

“I have grave concerns about Frank Campion in that regional chair role,” he says. “In the last regional council term, he was outspokenly pro-amalgamation and is likely to owe his first allegiance to the premier that appointed him and for whom he previously ran, under the Ontario PC banner.”

McGuinness also argues that weighted voting and the chair’s expanded powers will marginalize NOTL’s voice.

And Goettler?

“It may be the story of the goose and the golden egg,” he says. “We have the goose and we are benefiting with a golden egg. Let’s not destroy the goose. I will advocate, non-stop for Niagara-on-the-Lake to retain its unique heritage and identity.”

Good. There’s a sign in a ditch you can start with.

Garth Turner is a NOTL resident, journalist, author, wealth manager and former federal MP and minister. garth@garth.ca

Subscribe to our mailing list