Opinion: Unfortunately for us, America’s domestic crisis doesn’t stop at its borders

Kostiantynivka, Ukraine in January 2026. Since since Russia's invasion in February 2022, almost 18,000 civilians have been killed, and almost 58,000 injured. WIKIMEDIA

Keith McNenly
Special to The Lake Report

America is broken, and Americans cannot fix it alone.

The problem is no longer simply that the United States has elected an authoritarian president, or that its politics have become ugly and dysfunctional. The problem is that American foreign policy is now driven by contempt for democratic allies and admiration for strongmen.

Meanwhile, the institutions meant to restrain presidential power in the United States have repeatedly proved inadequate. Voters get their chance every four years. But a corrupt presidency can do enormous damage between elections: alliances weakened, trade relationships wrecked, military commitments broken, and international institutions undermined.

Americans have now delivered their verdict. After two years of this Trump presidency and Republican rule, they rejected his course in a sweeping midterm rebuke.

Yet Trump remains in office for two more years, with the full machinery of foreign policy and executive power still available to him. This is the brutal flaw in the assumption that elections alone can correct democratic collapse. An election can repudiate a president without removing him.

Congress can impeach him, but it does not. The Republican Party has repeatedly put loyalty, fear, or self-interest above constitutional duty. Impeachment exists on paper; in practice, it is not available when the country needs it most.

Any country that has relied on American steadiness should absorb that fact. Ukraine is a clear warning.

For years, Ukraine has been treated as though its survival were a bargaining chip in American politics. It has faced delays, threats and, now, retraction of the support it needs. That results in lethal human costs for Ukrainian civilians — since Russia’s invasion in February 2022, almost 18,000 have been killed, and almost 58,000 injured.

The world should look long and hard at Ukraine and imagine a similar future for its own cities, families and freedoms. Ukrainians are fighting because defeat would mean the loss of national independence and even greater loss of life.

The world has an obligation it has avoided for too long. Free nations should not merely wait for America’s next election. They should unite — politically, economically, militarily, and technologically — as an international freedom force.

Not against Americans, but in support of the American majority that has now demonstrably rejected the president’s destructive performance, yet lacks the constitutional means to stop it.

Isolating the American presidency means recognizing that civic majority as an ally. To isolate the presidency is to support the clear democratic direction Americans have expressed, but on a larger international stage.

Free nations should not normalize Trump and his representatives. A president who has lost the confidence of the American majority through his corruption and authoritarianism, should not receive the credibility, ceremony, access and deference that come with international engagement.

Allies are subjected to humiliation, threats and tariffs while authoritarian leaders are treated with a warmth and deference that should alarm everyone who believes in democratic government. Let authoritarian regimes embrace him. Democracies should not.

Canada has spoken clearly about the need for democracies to stand together and resist an undependable United States president. Canada should not have to stand alone in recognizing what is happening. Europe, Asia, and every democratic government that depends on a rules-based international order should be building alternatives now.

That means strengthening collective defence. It means expanding the production of weapons and ammunition for Ukraine, even if it requires short term sacrifice. It means securing independent military and domestic satellite networks, energy and supply-chain capacity. It means building trade relationships among democracies that cannot be held hostage by an American president using economic power as a weapon.

Many Americans are fighting courageously against the destructive forces in Washington, D.C. But they are constrained by a political system corrupted to protect presidential power.

This is the moment for democratic nations to finally accept that their security rests on recognizing the growing danger and then acting on it. America is its people, just as every democracy is its people — they have said Trump does not represent them. Trump represents only one person: himself.

Ukraine is fighting for its life on the front line. The rest of us must decide whether we are prepared to defend the world it is fighting for.

Niagara-on-the-Lake resident Keith McNenly was the chief administrator of the Town of Mono for 41 years.

Subscribe to our mailing list