
Arch-i-text: Hiding large buildings not as effective as designing them well
“If that fundamental building massing is incompatible with the existing streetscape, no amount of even expert jiggery-pokery will make it fit in,” writes Brian Marshall.

“If that fundamental building massing is incompatible with the existing streetscape, no amount of even expert jiggery-pokery will make it fit in,” writes Brian Marshall.

Since 2009, there hasn’t been a single neighbourhood in NOTL that has, as Brian Marshall writes, “escaped the incursion of one or more monster buildings disrupting the character of existing streetscapes.”

“Architects should have creative licence in their design process, provided that the end result (the new building) speaks to the landscape and respects the existing texture of the streetscape/neighbourhood,” writes Brian Marshall.

Front porches were a fixture of many homes during the 19th century, but with the rise of the automobile came their decline. “We lost something vital when porches largely disappeared,” writes Brian Marshall.

“It falls back on us to exercise every effort to choose representatives that are committed to ongoing public consultation, adhering to the direction of their constituents and steadfastly fulfilling the promises they made,” writes Brian Marshall.

“If you are one of the approximately 191,000 Niagara residents that live outside the boundaries of the three large cities, you have just been marginalized as a perpetual member of the minority,” writes Brian Marshall.

Six property owners have filed appeals to the Ontario Land Tribunal, stalling and potentially killing the expansion of Old Town’s heritage district, writes Brian Marshall.

“Is it any surprise that several smaller Ontario municipalities, with limited budgets and much tighter staff constraints, might opt for a draconian ‘hard line in the sand’ in their bylaws that denies access to any and all electoral activities?” writes Brian Marshall.

“Should any future council enact an interim control bylaw, underwritten by a duly compliant study, it will be largely legally unassailable,” writes Brian Marshall.

“In short, we have two candidates who, should they become lord mayor, will support and perpetuate the current system and one candidate who is willing to take what we’ve got and work toward something different,” writes Brian Marshall.

Premier Doug Ford’s “populist presentation” is “a facade behind which his government diligently works to centralize power, control and decision-making in the premier and cabinet ministers’ offices,” writes Brian Marshall.

“Hospitality, viticulture and agriculture are the career choices of a comparable few, not the many. The town of Niagara-on-the-Lake has focused for so long and with single-minded purpose on tourism that it has largely become a single-source economy,” writes Brian Marshall.

“We have to do more than put a Band-Aid on a broken system — otherwise, flooding will become the new norm,” writes Brian Marshall.

“As a collective, we fall into the rut of repeating the past simply because it is familiar and comfortable. But, then there are those who step out and create new and wonderful alternatives,” writes Brian Marshall.

“Without proper maintenance,” writes Brian Marshall, “in a short period of time, a drain can lose its effectiveness to manage water and help to prevent flooding.”

“While the current council does not bear full responsibility for the sad state of our infrastructure, its decision to greenlight development applications that rely on the same inadequate and failing infrastructure must be called into question,” writes Brian Marshall.

“What do we want our legislative bodies — municipal and provincial — to do to underwrite our shared wish relative to protecting Ontario’s heritage?” writes Brian Marshall.

Over the last five centuries, says Frank Lloyd Wright, what humanity has called architecture has been “phony”: “It was not innate, it wasn’t organic and it didn’t have the character of nature.”

“This non-profit took the bitter pill in favour of supporting the health and welfare of the community they are anchored in. And, that decision, in and of itself, is a shining example of a cultural institution that understands its vital connection to the local greater good,” writes Brian Marshall.

“The finished structure will not only become the dominant building within the Queen-Picton heritage conservation district, but abruptly clash with and diminish the built-heritage assets,” writes Brian Marshall of the new Royal George Theatre.

“Bit by bit, the legal underpinning by which a municipality can defensibly justify decisions to preserve its community in the face of a developer’s application are eroded,” writes Brian Marshall.

“Any correctly thinking council — one that represents the good of the town and its residents as opposed to commercial real estate investors — would support proper controls and a cap on the short-term rental market,” writes Brian Marshall.

“Ironic that NOTL, at about a quarter of the population of Portland, should have identical total (2022 vs. 2024) numbers for licensed short-term rentals,” writes Brian Marshall.

“At the very least, this application should not have been deemed complete until it complied with the provisions of the tribunal’s decision. Instead, it was given the go-ahead,” writes Brian Marshall.

“Nobody is sure who coined the term ‘sleepy little town,’ but one thing is for certain: in the past few years, the Town of Niagara-on-the-Lake certainly cannot be described in those terms,” writes Brian Marshall.
© All Rights Reserved, Niagara Now.

