NOTL Votes 2026: Voter turnout 52% in this year’s race, up from last election

Many engaged Niagara-on-the-Lake residents were at the community centre on Monday night to take in the election results together as they were broadcasted live in the auditorium. In total, 9,262 ballots were cast in the 2026 election. DAVE VAN DE LAAR

The people of Niagara-on-the-Lake have spoken — at least, 9,262 of them have.

The 2026 municipal election saw an uptick in voter turnout compared to the election four years ago, with around 52 per cent of registered voters casting their ballots, according to official results from the Town of NOTL’s website, publicized Tuesday.

In this case, it means 9,262 out of 17,684 registered voters took part in the election. That’s compared to 2022’s voter turnout of around 47 per cent.

Town clerk Grant Bivol, who oversaw the administration of the municipal election, said it’s encouraging to see this bump in voter participation.

“Any increase in participation is positive for local democracy and demonstrates that residents were engaged in the future of our community,” he told The Lake Report.

As of Friday evening, Oct. 30, Niagara-on-the-Lake posted the highest voter turnout in the Niagara region — voter turnout results for Welland were still pending.

Dave Van de Laar

Credit: DAVE VAN DE LAAR

A few dozen residents gathered at the NOTL Community Centre to watch the results come in live. NOTL had the highest voter turnout in the Niagara region and one of the highest in the province.

Internet voting ‘important’ part of election: town clerk

This year, the town introduced internet voting as an option, allowing people to cast their ballots online from Oct. 5 to 25 — it ended up being a big hit.

Of the 9,262 ballots cast, more than half of them were done online: 4,739. That’s 51 per cent.

In the mayoral race, Vaughn Goettler received 5,101 votes, making up 55 per cent of votes cast for the next lord mayor. Of those votes, 2,669 votes were cast online — that’s more than half.

Four years ago, after his first attempt to become lord mayor, he came third in the three-candidate race, getting 1,268 votes.

His opponents, current councillor Erwin Wiens and current regional councillor Andrea Kaiser, received 2,870 votes and 1,287 votes, respectively. For Wiens, that’s 31 per cent of mayoral votes, and for Kaiser, almost 14 per cent.

Internet voting was also well-utilized by Kaiser’s supporters: 653 of her votes were cast online, slightly more than half. For Wiens’ supporters, however, a little less than half of their votes were online, at 1,398.

Bivol said the town was happy with the rollout of internet voting.

“We were pleased with the implementation and believe it provided residents with an additional convenient and accessible way to participate in the election,” he said. “Online voting saw strong uptake and was an important component of this year’s voting process.”

Credit: RICHARD HARLEY

Vaughn Goettler supporters watch the results on the big screen at his election night party at his home. NOTL was one of a handful of municipalities in Niagara to have internet voting in its 2026 election.

Goettler gets big boost from Old Town

The official results show a breakdown of how people voted at the five polling centres in the five settlements: Old Town, Virgil, Glendale, St. Davids and Queenston.

Looking just at those five polling stations, the numbers indicate that the majority of Goettler’s support came from those who voted in Old Town: 1,368 votes were cast from the polling centre at the NOTL Community Centre, more than the total at the other four polling centres combined (1,064).

Kaiser also received the most number of votes from the Old Town poll, 272 votes, though the total number of votes combined at the other four polls tops that, at 362 votes.

Wiens, in contrast, saw the most success from the poll in Virgil, with 547 votes cast there. In Old Town, he received 486 votes. Combining all the polls except Virgil, 925 votes were cast for him in-person.

The most votes for a single candidate were cast for Gary Burroughs, with 5,394 votes (generally, a councillor gets the most number of votes for a single candidate in NOTL’s elections). This makes him NOTL’s next deputy lord mayor — Wiens was the deputy lord mayor these past four years.

Burroughs also fared well in Old Town, with 1,390 votes from that location. Like Goettler, his votes in Old Town outweigh the combined votes he received at the other four locations, but by 78 votes.

NOTL’s 2018 turnout yet to be topped

Earlier in October, two advance polls were also held at the NOTL Community Centre and Town Hall — those results were sorted into location results for Old Town and Virgil, respectively. At the community centre, 646 ballots were cast, while at Town Hall, 350 votes were cast.

While this election’s voter turnout is higher than the last election’s, it’s not quite as high as the turnout from 2018, when 59 per cent of eligible voters casted their ballot.

Speaking on how the administration of the 2026 election went overall, Bivol said he is “extremely proud” of town staff’s work.

“Elections require months of planning and preparation behind the scenes, and staff worked diligently to ensure residents could cast their ballots safely, securely and conveniently,” he said.

To view the official election results, visit the Town of NOTL’s website, or the results from the Association of Municipalities of Ontario.

Subscribe to our mailing list