Arch-i-text: A few wins for heritage preservation and good development in our town
“Sometimes the negative ‘press of events’ can lead us to believe that there are no ‘wins’ to celebrate. But, au contraire, there are,” writes Brian Marshall.
Author's Latest
Arch-i-text: Something is wrong with this picture
“There is an extremely disturbing trend in this province directed at marginalizing, diminishing or outright destruction of our shared history, built heritage and cultural landscapes,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: It’s time: Let’s go over the draft of the new official plan
“The more public input that is provided at this juncture, the more likely it is that staff — principally Fiona Main, senior policy planner — will be able to meet their published timeline,” writes Brian Marshall, in the first of a series of columns analyzing the town’s latest official plan draft.
Arch-i-text: Where is the Parliament Oak hotel project’s engineering report?
“In the event this report has not been completed — which would be odd given that we’re eight months into 2025 — the question then becomes why would staff be proceeding with this application in the absence of any form of validation of the applicant’s claims?” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: The importance of heritage conservation district — analyzing our neighbours, St. Catharines
in many jurisdictions, the sheer volume of important heritage assets which potentially stood to be lost was such that only a small fraction could be protected via Part IV designation.
Arch-i-text: From the Royal George to Virgil, planning decisions raise eyebrows in NOTL
“For the sake of the heritage district, town residents and the Shaw, I hope they succeed in tabling a design that will work,” writes Brian Marshall of the upcoming Royal George Theatre renovation.
Arch-i-text: It’s much more than all to do about nothing
“Change within the heritage district is one thing, but the wholesale flouting of the heritage district guidelines — specifically designed to preserve its ‘special character’ — is a horse of a different colour,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: Other points of concern in the new Royal George plans
The proponents of the Royal George Theatre redesign “are slavishly following the flawed protocols of the Venice Charter to produce a design which, in the view of several architects of my acquaintance, is utterly inappropriate within the context of the Queen–Picton historic district,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: A call to reconsider the Royal George proposal
“This application risks undermining the district’s founding principles by demolishing three 19th-century buildings and significantly altering the streetscapes of both Queen and Victoria streets,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: Focus on the real housing issue — the lack of affordable homes
“Building more of the same type of homes faster will do nothing but add to the current glut on the market of properties that a significant segment of our society simply cannot afford or, in other cases, do not want,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: Analyzing the Shaw’s future plans for the Royal George Theatre
“I support the Shaw’s overture for redevelopment of the Royal George. However, it must be done sympathetically, within context and not at the expense of the Part V heritage district,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: What makes these two development proposals different
“Good design costs no more than bad design, but bad design will scar a street, neighbourhood and community for decades,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: Of Bill 5 and other environmental matters
The clear-cutting of a forest in Virgil this year to make way for development is “only a single, relatively small, local example of the potential devastation which could, and likely will, be visited upon the landscape of this province should the Ford government’s Bill 5 be passed into law,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: Promises, proposals and observations on Wellness Estates
“The scale, massing and, as mentioned earlier, the height of the proposed design are acceptable, particularly given the break-up of the building’s faces into smaller staggered elements,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: The good and the bad in the Ford’s government new Bill 17
Brian Marshall details the introduction of Bill 17, the Protect Ontario by Building Faster and Smarter Act, introduced this spring, which, Marshall writes, contains provisions around development and home construction that are helpful, and others that present serious concerns.
Arch-i-text: Ford government attacks Ontario’s livability
Describing the newly introduced Bill 5, Brian Marshall writes, “Quite simply, the proposed legislation seeks to gut environmental protection, continuing Ford’s earlier assaults in 2020 and 2022.”
Arch-i-text: Another Rand lawsuit, and the future of the urban design and planning, part two
“Any review panel composed of members from outside the municipality will lack “skin in the game” and a personal understanding of the history, built character and design vision necessary to ensure their recommendations are not simply an academic expression unaligned with the wishes and desires of the established community,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: Why urban design and urban planning are not interchangeable
“It is a fundamental mistake for a municipality to assume that urban planners and urban designers are interchangeable. A city or town must draw upon the expertise of both professions to successfully realize urban development that serves the needs of its residents,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: Glencairn was an irreplacable part of Canadian history
“The loss feels like a death — not of a person, but a part of a person vested in a physical symbol of shared heritage. There’s simply no excuse,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: How zoning bylaws affect the design of homes in neighbourhoods
Analyzing the presence of a new home in Old Town NOTL, Brian Marshall writes, “This building is almost a textbook case demonstrating that even good architecture, when built in the wrong place, diminishes both its own qualities and the neighbouring streetscapes.”
Arch-i-text: The goal of the town’s next heritage conservation district plan
The new heritage conservation district study, a plan will create “a tool to manage change, the policies and guidelines accept the evolution of buildings and structures over time,” writes Brian Marshall, “while ensuring that any such change complements, rather than detracts from, the district’s unique character.”
Arch-i-text: Examining the latest study on the heritage conservation district
“This particular bylaw is … remarkably flexible — almost to the point of raising the question of whether it will accomplish the protection necessary for a successful study,” writes Brian Marshall of a new bylaw meant to halt development in a portion of Old Town for one year.
Arch-i-text: The restoration calculation — why historical buildings are worth saving
“A given piece of architecture, whether modest or grand, is a physical representation of the architect’s (or the property owner’s) creative expression, defined by its purpose, and set within — or sometimes in contrast with — the prevailing political, economic and cultural conditions of society,” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: Addressing some urban myths about designation
In examining a 2023 study from McMaster University that looked at the corelation between heritage designation and property value, “The authors concluded that heritage-designated properties ‘were associated with a positive increase in sale value’ and resulted in ‘an increase in sale price of residential properties,'” writes Brian Marshall.
Arch-i-text: Heritage designation, part two — determining a propety’s historic value
“On occasion, satisfying the criteria contained in this category can be straightforward, in cases wherein the facts are already established … or self-evident — however, far more often a significant amount of research is required,” writes Brian Marshall.
The Local Journalism Initiative is funded by the Government of Canada.
© All Rights Reserved, Niagara Now.