NOTL Votes 2026: Vaughn Goettler wins Niagara-on-the-Lake’s mayoral race

Vaughn Goettler embraces his wife Lauren after winning the election with 55.1 per cent of the vote. Richard Harley

Two experienced politicians lost their bid for Niagara-on-the-Lake’s top job Monday night, as voters handed the reins to a political newcomer and elected four incumbents to a smaller council.

Vaughn Goettler defeated deputy lord mayor Erwin Wiens and regional councillor Andrea Kaiser in Monday’s municipal election with an outright majority — 55.1 per cent of the vote, or 5,101 votes, according to unofficial results.

Wiens finished second with 2,870 votes, or 31 per cent, while Kaiser received 1,287 votes, or 13.9 per cent.

Incumbent Gary Burroughs topped the council race and will now become deputy lord mayor, while first-time councillors Weston Miller and Steve McGuinness claimed seats alongside four returning incumbents.

Credit: DAVE VAN DE LAAR

As the winners of the Niagara-on-the-Lake’s municipal election are called, Gary Burroughs excitedly celebrates the results — he won the councillor race and will be the town’s next deputy lord mayor.

The full council results

Voter turnout was 52.4 per cent, with 9,262 of NOTL’s 17,684 registered voters casting ballots, according to unofficial town results.

Burroughs led the 11-candidate council race with 5,394 votes, followed by fellow incumbent Sandra O’Connor with 4,973.

Newcomer Weston Miller finished third with 4,948 votes, while incumbent Andrew Niven secured fourth place with 4,413.

Steve McGuinness, another newcomer, was elected with 4,196 votes, and incumbent Tim Balasiuk claimed the sixth and final seat with 4,093.

Five candidates fell short.

Nicholas Colaneri received 3,501 votes, followed by Rick Mills with 2,893, incumbent Maria Mavridis with 2,852, incumbent Adriana Cater-Vizzari with 2,537 and Karen Jones-Taylor with 1,447.

Credit: DAVE VAN DE LAAR

Weston Miller finds out he’s going to be part of Niagara-on-the-Lake’s next term of council at an election night party in Chautauqua. He finished third in the councillor race.

Winners look ahead

For Goettler, the decisive victory was more than a win — it was a message from voters.

“I was truly humbled by the results, the overwhelming support throughout the entire community, and I take that very seriously,” he told The Lake Report.

“I saw it as kind of a mandate to bring the change that the town is requesting.”

Goettler said he hadn’t thought about winning by a majority, focusing instead on securing a victory.

He also welcomed the makeup of the new council, calling it a “very progressive team.”

“I’m excited to work with Gary Burroughs as the deputy lord mayor and all the councillors, both returning and new,” he said.

Goettler said he has watched Burroughs in action over the years and respects his experience at both the municipal and regional levels.

“I’m pretty happy to have Gary Burroughs as the deputy lord mayor,” he said. “But I don’t think there’s anybody who would have been a bad choice.”

For Andrew Niven, the election marked a first.

The only returning councillor who had never previously been elected, Niven joined the council table by appointment in October 2024 after Nick Ruller’s resignation.

Now, he’s earned a seat through the ballot box.

“I’m incredibly grateful to the residents of Niagara-on-the-Lake for their support and the confidence they’ve placed in me,” Niven told The Lake Report in a message following the election.

“I’m excited and ready to get to work, and I look forward to working with my fellow councillors.”

Defeated candidates react

After eight years at the council table, Wiens is leaving town hall.

“I’m disappointed in my loss,” he told The Lake Report after falling short in his bid for lord mayor.

But Wiens said he isn’t disappearing from community life and is looking ahead to what the incoming council will accomplish.

“We have to have faith in the electorate and we have to have faith in the council,” he said.

Kaiser, meanwhile, thanked the residents who supported her campaign and said she hopes the next council will work together constructively.

“I am hopeful for Niagara-on-the-Lake that we move forward collaboratively, positively,” she said.

Asked about the future of her push to change how Niagara Region divides policing costs among municipalities, she said she hopes Goettler will carry the effort forward.

Kaiser has been advocating for a review of the current property-assessment-based police cost model, arguing it places a disproportionate tax burden on communities such as NOTL.

“I certainly hope that the new mayor will pick up where I left off,” she said.

Credit: DAVE VAN DE LAAR

Erwin Wiens, about half an hour before the polls closed, at Corks Wine Bar & Eatery on Queen Street. He came in second place in this term’s election, after spending four years as part of council, serving as deputy lord mayor.

How election night unfolded

The first numbers began appearing around 8:40 p.m., showing Goettler leading the mayoral race with 63.5 per cent of the vote, followed by Wiens at 24.2 per cent and Kaiser at 12.3 per cent.

By 9 p.m., with more votes counted, Goettler’s lead had narrowed to 57.4 per cent, while Wiens climbed to 28.9 per cent and Kaiser stood at 13.7 per cent.

The three lord mayoral candidates maintained their positions throughout the evening, with Goettler holding the lead, Wiens in second and Kaiser in third.

Meanwhile, the first council results showed Burroughs, O’Connor, Miller, Niven, McGuinness and Balasiuk in the top six.

By 9 p.m., the same six candidates remained in the top six, a standing they maintained throughout the evening before ultimately securing seats on council.

Credit: DAVE VAN DE LAAR

Sandra O’Connor watches the election results at the NOTL Community Centre, as they begin to come in at 8:40 p.m. O’Connor came second in the councillors’ race.

A new council, a new structure

The election brings a significant change to the makeup of NOTL’s municipal government: the next council will have six councillors rather than eight, while the separate regional councillor position has been eliminated under provincial changes to Niagara’s governance structure.

That makes Goettler the town’s sole elected representative on regional council, where decisions on policing, infrastructure and regional services affect local taxpayers.

The town is scheduled to release its official election results Tuesday, Oct. 27. The new council’s inauguration is scheduled for Nov. 24.

paigeseburn@niagaranow.com

Subscribe to our mailing list