Opinion: Democracy won the U.S. midterm battle — the war is far from over

A symbolic blue wave sweeps through Washington, but Donald Trump still holds the pen — and the presidency. CHATGPT

Dear editor:

The U.S. midterm Tuesday night was historic: a blue tsunami for Democrats in Congress, the Senate, governorships and statehouses. The good news for Canada is that, even if Donald Trump tries to blame us for interference, our targeting of a few border and bourbon states could not possibly have caused this dramatic reawakening of the American conscience. I guess we’re off the hook  for this one. 

The bad news is that Trump is still there for two more years, with the power of the administration, the Department of Justice, the Department of War and the sharpie pen for executive orders. 

This election was a repudiation of Trump, Republican corruption and cruelty, and the harm done to the American economy. Don’t get too excited that it was a similar repudiation of his deleterious effects on citizens of other nations — it was not. This was a battle at home in the U.S., not on the world stage. 

Perhaps we will see the old America we loved as a neighbour and brother rise like a phoenix from the ashes of the past 10 years of Trump, and rejoin the family of world democracies. Only time will tell. 

There may be liberation or entrenchment. A wounded president is not necessarily a subdued one, and he has much to lose — and much to pay for. 

Everything the world and Canada have endured was done in less than two years. He has more than two years remaining. Around 55 Senate seats is not enough to remove him: conviction requires 67 votes. It’s unlikely that one or two Republicans would join Democrats to turf him out; a dozen is simply not possible. 

It’s hard to know where the pendulum of American politics points at the moment, only that it swings between the parties with regularity. Unlike Canada’s parliamentary system, where a vote of non-confidence can send an unpopular or crooked prime minister and government packing for a fresh election, the U.S. Constitution is not so flexible. 

Americans have a president for four years, come hell or high water. There are checks and balances, including impeachment, but it failed last time after he sent a mob to storm Congress. Neither the courts nor congressional victims could bring him to account. Clearly, the constitutional power balance tilts toward Republicans. 

Still, this moment is significantly encouraging. The American public took hold of the political pendulum and gave it a mighty shove to the left — toward love over hate, justice over corruption and strength over submission. 

It’s been a long fight, and the world will sleep better tonight. But the arc will begin its return, even before the new Congress is seated, and we should keep the Niagara sparkling wine corked for a little while yet.

Keith McNenly
NOTL

Subscribe to our mailing list